Home › Compare › Protolabs vs Fictiv, and the Direct-Shop Option
Compare

Protolabs vs Fictiv, and the Direct-Shop Option

Two on-demand approaches

Protolabs and Fictiv both deliver machined parts fast, from different foundations. Protolabs is a digital factory running its own plants for CNC machining, injection molding, sheet metal, and 3D printing, built for very quick prototype and bridge-production turnaround. Fictiv is a managed manufacturing platform that coordinates a vetted network of partner shops, layering its own quality management, DFM review, and program tracking over that network across machining, molding, casting, and more. Both quote online, handle a wide range of processes, and manage the logistics for you.

Where a direct shop fits

Both models put a platform between you and the shop floor. A direct machine shop removes that layer for the parts it specializes in.

Wexmar is a US CNC machine shop in Canastota, NY that ships nationwide. The shop runs 10 CNC lathes, 6 Mazak horizontal machining centers (3 and 4 axis), and 4 Maier MLK-32 Swiss lathes turning bar stock to 32mm diameter, with 2 Brown & Sharpe CMMs for in-house inspection. Work runs from one-off parts through long-run production. Wexmar is SAM registered (CAGE 16AD7), NIST 800-171 scored 110 of 110 in SPRS, DFARS-relevant, Buy American, and Made in USA. Quality is ISO 9001-aligned.

Wexmar does not aim to match the full process spread of either platform. It does not offer injection molding, sheet metal, 3D printing, casting, or 5-axis machining. What it does is turned, milled, and Swiss production parts, made in the United States, inspected on in-house CMMs, with the machinist reachable directly. For a turned or milled metal part you want made domestically and held to a drawing, that direct line is the point.

Side by side

FactorProtolabsFictivWexmar
ModelDigital factoryManaged partner networkDirect machine shop
Who makes the partProtolabs plantsVetted partner shopsWexmar, in-house
Process breadthWideVery wideTurning, milling, Swiss
Swiss to 32mmLimitedVia network4 Maier MLK-32 Swiss lathes
InspectionFactory QAPlatform QMS over networkIn-house CMM
US complianceUS plantsVaries by partnerSAM, SPRS 110/110, Buy American
QuoteInstantOnlineInstant from a drawing

How to choose

Pick Protolabs for the fastest in-house prototype turnaround across several processes. Pick Fictiv for a managed network with program oversight across a wide process range. Pick a direct shop like Wexmar when the part is turned or milled metal, you want one maker accountable for the tolerance, and domestic production matters for Buy American or defense-adjacent orders. See CNC turning or get an instant quote.

Materials, tolerances, and lead time

Wexmar machines common and specialty metals for turned and milled work, including aluminum, stainless, carbon and alloy steels, brass, and bronze, with material choice driven by the drawing. The four Maier MLK-32 Swiss lathes handle small, tight-tolerance turned parts in bar stock to 32mm diameter, while the 6 Mazak horizontal machining centers cover 3 and 4 axis milled work. Every job can be checked on the shop's two Brown & Sharpe CMMs before it ships, and first-article and in-process inspection scale with the run. Lead time tracks material availability and quantity rather than a queue in someone else's plant, and the same drawing that priced the job runs it from prototype through production. Send a print to the instant quote page to start.

All product and company names are trademarks of their respective owners and are used here for identification and comparison only.

Frequently asked questions

How do Protolabs and Fictiv differ?

Protolabs makes parts in its own plants as a digital factory. Fictiv manages a vetted partner network with its own quality system layered on top.

Where does Wexmar fit?

Wexmar is a US direct machine shop for turned, milled, and Swiss parts, with in-house CMM inspection and direct access to the machinists.

Can Wexmar do molding or 3D printing like these platforms?

No. Wexmar does turning, milling, and Swiss machining only. For molding, casting, sheet metal, or 3D printing, one of the platforms is the better fit.

Is Wexmar suitable for government-related work?

Yes. Wexmar is SAM registered (CAGE 16AD7), DFARS-relevant, Buy American, and scored 110 of 110 in SPRS.

Send drawings, get a quote

Email a print, STEP file, or solicitation package. Quotes include material, machine time, finishing, inspection, and freight to your dock.

Email RFQ to ron@backwell.com  Call (315) 400-2654

No drawing upload here. The RFQ page gives you a direct email link for files.